Rhetorical Frameworks

Table Topics

Most table topics will fall into 1 of 5 categories, easily remembered with the acronym POACH:

  • Personal Story
  • Opinion
  • Advice
  • Comparisons
  • Hypotheticals

Suggested frameworks

Category Framework Steps
Personal Story SAR Situation, Action, Result
Opinion PRE Point, Reason, Example (repeat)
Advice SPSB Situation, Problem, Solution, Benefit
Comparisons SDI Similarities, Differences, Insight
Hypotheticals IDR Imagine, Describe, Reflect

There are hundreds of these frameworks for different situations — and of course you can always come up with your own, or refine one of the above.

See also: next table topic, table topics research paper

Office Situations

Frameworks worth having on hand for work conversations — feedback, decisions, writing, coaching, problem-solving.

Feedback & difficult conversations

Situation Framework Steps
Giving feedback SBI Situation, Behaviour, Impact
Giving feedback (with an ask) COIN Context, Observation, Impact, Next steps
Difficult conversation DESC Describe, Express, Specify, Consequence
Difficult conversation (high-stakes) STATE Share facts, Tell your story, Ask, Talk tentatively, Encourage testing

Coaching & 1:1s

Situation Framework Steps
Coaching a report GROW Goal, Reality, Options, Will
Behavioural interview / performance review STAR Situation, Task, Action, Result
Project retro 4Ls Liked, Learned, Lacked, Longed for
Quick retro SSC Start, Stop, Continue

Decisions & prioritization

Situation Framework Steps
Prioritizing a backlog MoSCoW Must have, Should have, Could have, Won’t have
Weighing an option SWOT Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, Threats
Deciding under time pressure OODA Observe, Orient, Decide, Act
Managing your time Eisenhower Matrix Urgent × Important quadrants

Writing & presenting

Situation Framework Steps
Status update PREP Point, Reason, Example, Point
Memo / exec summary SCQA Situation, Complication, Question, Answer
Leading with the answer BLUF Bottom Line Up Front
Pitching an idea PSB Problem, Solution, Benefit
Presenting data or an insight WWW What, So What, Now What

Problem-solving

Situation Framework Steps
Root cause 5 Whys Ask “why” 5 times to find the root cause
Root cause (visual) Fishbone Group causes by category (People, Process, Equipment, …) around an effect
Continuous improvement PDCA Plan, Do, Check, Act
Rigorous process improvement DMAIC Define, Measure, Analyze, Improve, Control

Senior lunches / informal conversations

Low-stakes, unstructured, and off the record — but this is really just table topics again. Most of what comes up is still a personal story, an opinion, advice, a comparison, or a hypothetical, so POACH applies directly. A few situations specific to informal chats with senior people are worth having ready on top of that:

Situation Framework Steps
Talking about your work without sounding like you’re bragging SCR Situation, Challenge, Result (frame the result around the team/impact, not just yourself)
Asked your opinion on something sensitive (strategy, a reorg, politics) ABC Acknowledge the question, Bridge to safer ground, Communicate the point you actually want to land
Signalling career ambition tactfully IEA Interest, Evidence, Ask
Making small talk / building rapport FORD Family, Occupation, Recreation, Dreams
Showing you’re listening Open → Narrow Ask an open question, then a specific follow-up that shows you picked up on their answer
Pulling technical knowledge/wisdom out of them on something you don’t know deeply SEER Story (“walk me through a time when…” — gets tacit knowledge, not a textbook answer), Explain (get them to explain a term/concept simply — checks your understanding as you go), Edge cases (ask what trips people up or goes wrong — this is where the real expertise lives), Rule of thumb (ask if they have a heuristic or shortcut — the compressed “wisdom” version)

As with table topics — this list will keep growing. Worth pruning down to whichever ones actually stick in practice.


This site uses Just the Docs, a documentation theme for Jekyll.